MEPT maintains a valuation process that is one of the most
thorough and objective of any open-end fund. Each asset in the MEPT portfolio
is appraised annually by an independent MAI-designated member of the Appraisal
Institute who must be selected and engaged by NewTower Trust Company, MEPT’s
trustee. The appraisal process is staggered throughout the calendar year so
that independent appraisers value approximately 25% of the total portfolio each
quarter. Inherent in this appraisal scheduling program is a concerted effort
to obtain ongoing valuation analysis and market data to assist the Trustee’s
valuation team who continuously monitor all relevant factors affecting the performance
of each asset as well as the entire portfolio.
Each property in the MEPT portfolio not being independently
appraised during any quarter is “marked-to-market" under the direction of NewTower
Valuation Services. This extensive quarterly valuation process not only addresses
material changes in the physical or financial condition of each asset and associated
market environment, it further utilizes information from recent MAI appraisals
and MEPT asset managers as well as numerous market data sources including Kennedy
Associates Real Estate Counsel, LP’s proprietary portfolio database, local appraisers,
brokers, property managers, and published comparative market and property information.
NewTower engages multiple national valuation firms to provide
independent appraisals for MEPT assets. Conflicts are avoided through the use
of a comprehensive bid and review process prior to engagement of an appraisal
firm. NewTower also has a detailed list of requirements that must be met by
every appraiser submitting a bid. In addition, it is the general practice of
NewTower to engage an appraiser for no more than three consecutive years on
the same MEPT asset.
Once the appraisal is received, NewTower Valuation Services
(staffed with MAI-designated appraisers) and MEPT asset managers thoroughly
review each report and accompanying discounted cash flow analysis to evaluate
the valuation methodologies employed and ensure the accuracy of property descriptive
and financial information (total building and net rentable areas, rent roll,
expenses, occupancy, etc.) as well as critical market data (appropriateness
of concluded market rental rates, tenant improvement allowances, leasing concessions,
supply and demand characteristics, etc.)
As an additional safeguard, MEPT retains an independent appraisal
review firm, PricewaterhouseCoopers, to assist in verifying the accuracy of
the appraisal process by reviewing each report to determine compliance, completeness,
appropriateness of methodology, accuracy of calculations, and reasonableness
of conclusions. The independent review firm engaged must concur with each MAI
appraisal before it is finalized and recommended for acceptance by the Trustee
on behalf of MEPT.
The methodology of the appraisal and review process is also
examined annually by MEPT’s external auditor, KPMG, and by the Maryland Division
of Financial Regulation every 12 to 18 months.
|